Old Towne Preservation Association
  • About
    • OTPA History
    • Board of Directors >
      • Previous Boards of Directors
    • Contact
    • Old Towne Photos
  • Events
    • State of Old Towne Forum 2022
    • Street Fair
    • The Art of Wine - Hilbert Museum
    • Ice Cream Social
    • Holiday Decorating Contest >
      • Holiday Decorating Contest - 2021
      • Holiday Decorating Contest- 2020
      • Holiday Decorating Contest 2019
      • OHG/CFO Orange Inspirational Signs - 2020
    • Halloween Decorating Contest >
      • Halloween Decorating 2021
      • Halloween Decorating 2020
      • Halloween Decorating 2019
      • Halloween Decorating 2018
    • Historic Home Tours >
      • Home Tour 2022
      • Home Tour 2019
      • Home Tour 2017
      • Home Tour 2015
    • General Meetings >
      • RSVP - General Meeting 2022
    • OTPA On-the-Road & Tours
  • Buy Tickets / Make a Donation
  • News
    • Blog
    • Newsletters
    • Killefer School
    • Chapman's Proposed Expansion News
  • Preservation
    • OTPA in Action >
      • Preservation Issues
      • DRC Meetings
      • City Council Meetings - Speak Up!
      • Planning Commission Meetings - Speak Up!
    • Map of Old Towne Orange
    • Historic Cypress Street Barrio
    • Tradespersons
    • OTPA Plaques Info
    • Plaques Database Input
    • Design/Build Standards / Code Enforcement >
      • Design Build Standards - Adopted Dec 2017
      • Code Enforcement / Design Standards
      • Code Enforcement - Notify City
    • Mills Act Info
    • FAQs
  • Get Involved
    • Become a Member
    • Membership Information
    • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Join Free Email Subscription
  • Business Members
  • OTPA STORE

OTPA in Action

OTPA in Action - 2020

OTPA has been advocating for Old Towne for three decades on important preservation and renovation projects impacting our unique historic community. In our continuing effort to protect our valuable historic resources, OTPA has recently held meetings with City Staff members, City Council members, Old Towne Orange neighborhood representatives, members of the Orange Barrio Historical Society, and Chapman University's President Daniele Struppa regarding recent and ongoing issues here in Old Towne Orange. Below are current projects/issues:

While there will undoubtedly be new issues to tackle in 2018, there are still several items from prior years that will continue into 2018:
  • Chapman University proposed expansion​
  • Kellar Watson house proposed demolition
  • Killefer School site development

​Continue to watch this space for updates!
Get Involved - We Need Your Support! Join Today!

March 25, 2020 - Presentation by Hicham Semaan on the proposed restoration / adaptive reuse of the historic structure at 137 E Maple Ave in Old Towne Orange:

Picture
December 12, 2017 - Old Towne Preservation Standards Updated — Orange City Council Approves Revisions 

The Orange City Council, at its monthly meeting December 12, approved the updated Historic Preservation Standards for Old Towne. OTPA endorsed the updates, and urged vigorous and consistent enforcement.

For years, the Old Towne Preservation Association has called for a full review followed by adoption of needed revisions to better assist owners of homes and businesses who want to restore, remodel or make additions to their property.


"OTPA has worked closely with the City’s Community Development staff to make sure the updated standards would protect the charm and unique character of Old Towne,” said Jeff Frankel, OTPA’s reservation Committee chair.   ​
Details of the revised standards were presented to the public in a series of meetings inviting review and comment, and were then approved by the City’s Design Review Committee and the Planning Commission.  

Frankel and OTPA Vice President Tony Trabucco both worked with the City on the revisions and were present for the important decision.

President Sandy Quinn addressed the Council prior to the vote: 

“The Old Towne Preservation Association urges your approval of the updated Historic Preservation Standards for Old Towne, and is grateful to the City’s Community Development Director Bill Crouch and his staff for devoting the immense amount of time and effort necessary to complete these revisions and bring them forward in a comprehensive, publicly reviewed and supported package for approval.  

The updated Standards are a masterpiece in preservation guidance, and will be a model for other 
communities throughout the country which are stepping up to protect their past.     

We particularly thank Marissa Moshier, the Community Development’s Historic Preservation Planner, for being the Godmother of the updating standards and for her desire to make the process inclusive and transparent.   

OTPA collaborated and co-sponsored one of the several outreach meetings for public comment, and 
Marissa gave a thorough presentation and responded articulately to all questions and comments.   Anna Pehoushek and Marissa Moshier sure know their stuff!

But the Standards must be enforced to be useful, and OTPA works hard to assist the City in making sure the standards are followed.   

We not only urge your approval this evening, but urge the Council, Design Review Committee, 
Planning Commission, and all staff to vigorously, consistently and aggressively make sure these Standards 
are followed and enforced every day, in every instance where they apply.   

A strong commitment to enforcement is essential to making sure Old Towne remains the amazing treasure it is today.”
Click here for a copy of the updated standards

Design Standards Town Hall Meeting - August 23, 2017

Click to View OC Register Coverage of the Town Hall Meeting

2016 Old Towne Orange Preservation Issues:

Picture
​CONGRATULATIONS, OTPA! The Old Towne Preservation Association was honored with the Orange Public Library Foundation’s 2016 Legacy Award at the foundation's annual awards celebration dinner on Sunday evening, June 5, at the Jones Victorian Estate in Orange.

OTPA was honored as it “has protected and enhanced the quality of life for our citizens, preserving the historic legacy of our homes; buildings and community; and creating a visual, cultural and educational living legacy.”  We’re pleased to accept, and proud of
                                                                             the recognition on this, OTPA’s 30th anniversary.



PictureClick to Enlarge
 May 17, 2016

Killefer School - Proposed Annexation of Surplus Property


Representatives from OTPA attended the "7-11" committee meeting regarding the request for annexation of surplus property adjacent to the Killefer School and Richland School properties, and in the time allocated voiced our opposition to the project in its current proposed state, due to the volume and massing of the project, the fact that it almost totally obscures the Lemon St. elevation and its character-defining features, and will significantly impact the surrounding neighborhoods during both the construction and operational phases. The committee voted to recommend to the school board that the adjacent parcel in question be declared surplus and be made available to the developer for sale.  OTPA objects on the grounds that this parcel was not made available to other bidders on the property, (the developer requested that the property be designated "surplus") and that its "highest and best use" is likely to the benefit of the Richland School for parking or outdoor recreational space for their high school students, versus to create additional parking capability
for a for-profit developer. At the May 3, 2016 meeting, a recommendation was made that "...the Southern Parcel be sold utilizing
a waiver process to allow direct negotiations, if possible" which appears to favor the current developer (see meeting minutes, below).

While OTPA supports the addition of incremental student housing, we are also concerned that as this is a private housing development, it will not be subject to the same oversight provided for Chapman-owned on-campus housing (Resident Assistants, Campus Security, etc.). Make your voice heard at the next Orange Unified School District Board meeting, Thursday, May 26th at 7:00PM the District Office Board Room - Building "H"; 1401 North Handy Street • Orange, CA 92867
  • Click here for minutes of the May 3, 2016 7-11 Committee Meeting
  • Click here for minutes of the April 13, 2016 7-11 Committee Meeting.


PictureClick to View / Download
April 27, 2016

Letter from California Preservation Foundation (CPF)

In April, Jeff Frankel, OTPA Preservation Chair and several City of Orange staff members attended the California Preservation Association Conference in Sacramento.

Attached is a letter from CPF thanking OTPA for our sponsorship. In addition to OTPA's CPF sponsorship we also sponsored four City staff members that included Community Development Director Bill Crouch, Assistant Director Anna Pehoushek, Planners Marissa Moshier, and Kelly Ribuffo. All came away from the conference with valuable information and knowledge that will prove to be beneficial in addressing preservation issues here in our district.

It is not only the educational sessions and workshops that are beneficial, but the conference also provides the opportunity to network with other individuals like ourselves form historic communities as well as preservation professionals from all over the State. Next year the conference will be held in Pasadena, affording OTPA additional opportunities to assist with the continuing education of City of Orange staff and OTPA board members, in an ongoing effort to assist with the preservation efforts in Old Towne Orange!


PictureClick to Enlarge
January 25, 2016

Kellar Watson House Proposed Demolition Meeting


The developer who is seeking to demolish the iconic Watson Kellar house requested a meeting with OTPA representatives to discuss OTPA's opposition to the developer's plan. OTPA reiterated its concerns that not only was the developer proposing to demolish an historic resource (that is the Southern gateway to Old Towne), but that the scale, massing, and density were inappropriate for Old Towne.
For additional details regarding the meeting, click here.



January 25, 2016

Coming soon:
  • The Pie Hole - Replacing The Grinder at the corner of Maple and Glassell will be The Pie Hole, already a popular stop for sweet treats in Pasadena and downtown LA.  OTPA members will be invited to a special pre-opening sneak preview.
  • Squeeze Me - Another new Plaza eatery coming soon is Squeeze Me, offering an interesting variety of hamburger specialities. It replaces 149 Sports Grill on N. Glassell.
  • Aussie Bean - Just about open:  the Aussie Bean on Maple across from the Filling Station gets its signage before brewing up a menu of great coffee specialties. Opens in early February.​
  • Watson's - The new Watson's Soda Fountain and Cafe adds a corner sign.

January 25, 2016

While not a local preservation issue, The National Trust for Historic Preservation recently (January 12, 2016) ran an article titled 10 Tips: Restoring vs. Rehabilitating Your Historic House that we thought would be an interesting read for our members and any other preservation-minded individuals in Orange and surrounding communities. Preservation is everyone's responsibility!

January 2016
​

It won’t be long before this historic Old Towne landmark is back in business. The Old Towne Preservation Association is working with new owner Billy Skeffington to host the exclusive pre-opening event when members and special guests will be the first to experience the new look, atmosphere and menu. We’ve been inside, and it looks terrific!

Picture

2015 Old Towne Orange Preservation Issues:

DECEMBER 14, 2015 - PROPOSED DEMOLITION OF KELLAR WATSON HOME

OTPA and the surrounding community are watching closely the proposed demolition of the Kellar Watson home located at 655 S. Glassell (straddles the lot between Glassell St. and Orange St., just North of, and adjacent to, Hart Park. The proposed development would level the existing historic home and replace it with 7 multi-family dwellings with a total of 22 bedrooms.  

From the City Staff Report:

"May warrant special consideration for local planning. It was constructed in 1941 by Kellar Watson, Sr., founder of Watson’s Drugs, the oldest business in the City of Orange and the oldest continuously operating pharmacy in the Orange County. Though the property does not meet the 1940 DOC restriction for Historic standing, it is a property of local historic interest due to its identification with a person of significant local importance and its striking interior architecture.

The property was purchased by Kellar E. Watson, Jr. in 1938 and the residence was constructed in 1942. As discussed in some detail in the attached DPR forms, Watson’s father was the founder of the iconic Watson Drug Store and Soda Fountain, which is widely considered the City’s oldest and best known business. Watson, Jr. followed in his father’s footsteps, taking over the drug store after his father’s retirement in 1928. Watson, Jr. served as pharmacist until his own retirement in 1965. During that time, he was well-known in the community both for his business and his community involvement."

Picture

CHAPMAN UNIVERSITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE FORMED - FIRST MEETING NOVEMBER 5, 2015

At the suggestion of the Old Towne Preservation Association, Chapman University leadership has named a community advisory committee to review school/neighborhood issues. The first meeting will be Thursday, November 5. Chancellor Daniele Struppa, who will succeed Jim Doti next year as president, will participate along with other senior Chapman officials.

Click here for additional details.

SEPTEMBER 2, 2015 - KILLEFER SCHOOL SITE - PROJECT PROPOSED BEFORE DRC
The photos below illustrate a recent proposal by the development group currently in escrow on the historic Killefer School site. The project includes approximately 285 beds of private housing (and underground parking for approximately 160 cars), intended for use/rent by Chapman University students. OTPA's concern with the project is the scale and massing of the new construction, coupled with the fact that it completely masks the historic character-defining features of the West elevation of the historic building. In addition, the infill project as proposed will also create impacts to the surrounding historic neighborhood.  While OTPA is sensitive to the issue that any rehabilitation and/ or restoration of this National Register site must be financially viable, it must also be sympathetic to the historic structure, site, and surrounding neighborhood.

Picture
Click on photos above to enlarge

AUGUST 12, 2015 - SIDEWALK REPAIRS
An astute OTPA member noticed a substandard repair of the brick sidewalk on East Chapman a couple of weeks ago, and asked OTPA if anything could be done to resolve the issue.  OTPA contacted the City of Orange, and they promptly sent out a repair crew to properly repair the sidewalk. Thank you City of Orange for helping OTPA to preserve the character of Old Towne Orange!

The "Before" Picture
And "After" - Much Better!


JULY 31, 2015 HOBBS BATTERY SIGN:
As many of you know, Orange resident Don Richards Thornhill created a Go-Fund-Me campaign to fund the removal of graffiti. He and artist Steve Vandemon met with Marissa Moshier, an associate planner in historic preservation at the City of Orange. Since the graffiti is marring a building in our historic district, the removal must have city approval. According to Moshier, the upper portion of the sign appears to be the original, historic paint. However, the lower portion of the sign was repainted when it was tagged a few years ago. The repainted portion consists of a base layer of colored paint covered with a soft, chalky lime or white wash to give the sign its aged appearance from the street. The graffiti is primarily on the repainted section, over the soft whitewash layer. Because the graffiti is painted on top of this very soft, powdery material, they are still investigating the best options for removal and don’t have a firm start date yet.
Picture
"Before" - Click to Enlarge
Picture
"After" - Click to Enlarge

PictureClick to Enlarge
JULY 2015 KILLEFER SCHOOL UPDATE:
In mid-July, representatives of OTPA met with the developers currently in escrow on the Killefer school site to take a preliminary look at the project, prior to it being submitted to the DRC (watch this space under "Public Meetings - Speak Up!" —'ll publish the date and any pertinent documents for you to review prior to the meeting, should you wish to attend to either support or oppose the project).  Additional details of the project can be found in a recent (April 2015) OC Register article. Click here to view article.


PictureClick to Enlarge
JULY 2015 THE PATIO RESTAURANT - UPDATE:
After meeting with the applicant, the applicant revised their proposed plan to preserve the historic path of travel and right-of-way for pedestrians. OTPA withdrew our appeal just prior to the July 14th City Council meeting, upon receipt of confirmation by the City and the applicant that the revised plan met the standards.





PictureClick to Enlarge
JUNE 2015 THE PATIO RESTAURANT: The original proposal for this restaurant, replacing the Heavenly Hostess store between Wells Fargo and Citizen’s Business Bank, created a fenced barrier from the restaurant front all the way to the outer sidewalk. The Planning Commission approved the project, which resulted in an instant formal appeal from OTPA. We oppose the unprecedented closing of our public pedestrian sidewalks. Other Plaza restaurants including Bagel Me, Felix, and Two’s Company, serve in the center pink area designated for dining, but do not obstruct public use of the sidewalk. We consulted with City staff, and then presented a new plan to the applicants.  They have agreed to withdraw their request to close the sidewalk, and have submitted a revised plan to the City. We plan to watch this process carefully to make sure our sidewalks remain open.



PictureClick to Enlarge
METROLINK PARKING STRUCTURE:
No one questions the need for additional parking in Old Towne, and the City is doing something about it. The Metrolink structure will replace the existing parking area at the corner of Maple and Lemon with a multi-level facility for 611 vehicles.  OTPA has been frequently consulted and our input has been well received by City Community Development staff.   It is a joint project with the Orange County Transportation Authority to accommodate the growing number of local Metrolink passengers and the demand for more downtown parking.   cost is estimated at $20.4 million, with the Transportation Authority funding $16.7 million, and the remaining $3.7 million coming from former Orange Redevelopment Agency bond funds.     



PictureClick to Enlarge
URTH CAFFE:   
OTPA officials met with the owners and architects of the restaurant under construction in the two story building which housed law offices in the southwest corner of the Plaza, next to Starbucks. Originally called the Armor Block, it was built as a one story in the late 1800s. A second floor was added in 1907 and it was renamed the Ainsworth Building. The new owner is a preservationist and plans to return this historic structure to its original appearance. His presentation to DRC was one of the most thorough and preservation themed that we’ve seen.   The menu will feature organic fresh roasted coffees and signature sandwiches, salads and desserts.  



PictureClick to Enlarge
THE AUSSIE BEAN:
We’re sorry to see our friend Judy Schroeder close her gallery and studio, but were pleased to meet with the new tenants who are restoring the building and creating an interesting coffee and pastry shop with a special roasting process. They’re eager to do the preservation correctly, and we’re already working with them. Opening in September.



PictureClick to Enlarge
THE BLAZE PIZZA:
Open and doing well, and pleased with our request that they keep the building’s newly revealed large leaded prism glass transom windows in place during restoration and paint removal.   



PictureClick to Enlarge
JASON’S BY THE CIRCLE:   
This new restaurant is replacing Ways and Means at Shaffer and Chapman, and will open in mid-July offering a diverse menu of comfort food and cocktails seven days a week. Chef Jason, who has been one of Orange County’s leading caters for several years, did a terrific job catering OTPA’s Preservation Award dinner in May. Jason has consulted with OTPA and we have found no preservation issues in this non-contributing structure. 



PictureClick to Enlarge
THE MASONIC TEMPLE AND BANK OF ITALY BUILDING:
Wonder what’s going on with this historic structure at 71 Plaza Square? It’s facade work to repoint the brick and make the building more earthquake stable. OTPA is glad they’re using the Spectra Company, a top preservation specialist.  



PictureClick to Enlarge
April 2015 - NUTWOOD PLACE MONUMENT RESTORED:

OTPA sponsored the leveling (as in making perpendicular to the ground) of the Nutwood Place Monument at the intersection of Orange St and La Veta Ave. If you've noticed it leaning over the years, well, it leans no more. Drive on by and take a look!




PictureClick to Enlarge
HISTORIC KILLEFER SCHOOL SAVED!

In a victory for the Old Towne Preservation Association’s efforts to save the historic Killefer School, the California State Historic Resources Commission agreed with OTPA and voted unanimously that the school should be listed on the National Register of Historic Places and protected from demolition by developers. “The preservation association is proud of its success in assuring that Orange will continue to enjoy this landmark educational structure, which played an important part in our community history,” said Jeff Frankel, OTPA’s Preservation chair. “This is a huge victory for OTPA and our mission of protecting, preserving and enhancing our unique character.”

The 74-year-old elementary school at 541 N. Lemon Street is more than historic and significant in time and architecture: It enjoys a dramatic place in California cultural history. Killefer is believed to be the first school in California to voluntarily integrate students before a group of Mexican American parents challenged segregation and won their case in the Mendez vs Westminster court ruling of 1944. Such cases were instrumental in the Brown vs Board of Education decision three years later.

The 1.7 acre school and surrounding property is still owned by the Orange Unified School District, which put it up for sale last year. Several developers — and Chapman University — made bids. The first bidder, the Olson Company, proposed to demolish the school and build townhouses. Olson pulled out when the Old Towne Preservation Association objected and retained preservation consultants to coordinate the process for achieving national registration as a permanent historic building.

The only opposition came from the Orange Unified School District, which voted in a closed session not to support the school’s listing as a historic landmark. The District had a representative in attendance at the State Historic Resources Commission hearing on Jan. 28 in Sacramento as did OTPA. The commission is a nine-member review board appointed by the governor for identification, registration, and preservation of California’s cultural heritage. Its recommendations are reviewed and approved by the National Park Service for listing on the National Register of Historic Places, which is the next step for the Killefer School.

The listing will ensure that the school building cannot be demolished, but the structure can be adaptively reused by the property owner.

Other bidders are now exploring possibilities.


Picture
Membership
Old Towne Preservation Association
P.O. Box 828
Orange, CA 92856
714-639-6840
Info@OTPA.org
Board Member Access

FOLLOW US ON FACEBOOK
  • About
    • OTPA History
    • Board of Directors >
      • Previous Boards of Directors
    • Contact
    • Old Towne Photos
  • Events
    • State of Old Towne Forum 2022
    • Street Fair
    • The Art of Wine - Hilbert Museum
    • Ice Cream Social
    • Holiday Decorating Contest >
      • Holiday Decorating Contest - 2021
      • Holiday Decorating Contest- 2020
      • Holiday Decorating Contest 2019
      • OHG/CFO Orange Inspirational Signs - 2020
    • Halloween Decorating Contest >
      • Halloween Decorating 2021
      • Halloween Decorating 2020
      • Halloween Decorating 2019
      • Halloween Decorating 2018
    • Historic Home Tours >
      • Home Tour 2022
      • Home Tour 2019
      • Home Tour 2017
      • Home Tour 2015
    • General Meetings >
      • RSVP - General Meeting 2022
    • OTPA On-the-Road & Tours
  • Buy Tickets / Make a Donation
  • News
    • Blog
    • Newsletters
    • Killefer School
    • Chapman's Proposed Expansion News
  • Preservation
    • OTPA in Action >
      • Preservation Issues
      • DRC Meetings
      • City Council Meetings - Speak Up!
      • Planning Commission Meetings - Speak Up!
    • Map of Old Towne Orange
    • Historic Cypress Street Barrio
    • Tradespersons
    • OTPA Plaques Info
    • Plaques Database Input
    • Design/Build Standards / Code Enforcement >
      • Design Build Standards - Adopted Dec 2017
      • Code Enforcement / Design Standards
      • Code Enforcement - Notify City
    • Mills Act Info
    • FAQs
  • Get Involved
    • Become a Member
    • Membership Information
    • Volunteer Opportunities
    • Join Free Email Subscription
  • Business Members
  • OTPA STORE